Larry Magid: Internet Governance Forum focuses on protecting kids

I traveled to Lillestr m Norway in late June for the annual United Nations Internet Governance Forum IGF Unlike several UN gatherings that primarily involve leadership agents the IGF is a multistakeholder event bringing together representatives from governments universities advocacy groups and the tech industry from around the world I attended on behalf of ConnectSafely the nonprofit internet safety organization where I serve as CEO Related Articles Magid The disappearing off switch Magid Designing digital safety with youth in mind Magid Using ChatGPT for everyday tasks Magid Make sure you prep all your tech for passage Larry Magid A laptop built for AI Although it doesn t pass resolutions or make binding decisions the IGF serves as a space for dialogue and collaboration As someone who has long worked at the intersection of instrument guidelines and online safety I find it an invaluable opportunity to share insights contribute to the conversation and learn from policymakers researchers and fellow advocates Algorithm impact I was excited about a panel titled Securing Child Safety in the Age of the Algorithms an key topic that deserves serious consideration But the first speaker Leanda Barrington-Leach of the FiveRights Foundation painted an overly pessimistic picture arguing that algorithm-driven platforms are not just risky for children but downright engineered to harm them She alleged a slippery slope where a child can go from a simple search for slime to porn in just a single click or from trampolining to pro-anorexia in just three clicks and nudge to self-harm in clicks I suppose that might be viable but I really couldn t replicate either when I tried using Google She wasn t alone in sounding the alarm The panel featured representatives from UNICEF the European Commission and senior establishment bureaucrats from Norway and Sierra Leone particular of whom laid out a sobering portrait of what they view as a constituents physical condition situation Children drawn into dangerous digital spaces by algorithms designed to maximize engagement often at the expense of well-being Concerns lack nuance To be fair particular of the concerns raised are legitimate There s no denying that children are exposed to inappropriate content and that features like infinite scroll and autoplay can lead to overuse Algorithms designed to serve up content the system believes you want can reinforce bad habits and encourage repetitive consumption But they can also enhance discovery making platforms more engaging and useful As I listened I couldn t help but feel that the narrative lacked nuance and gave parents and children too little credit I m not nearly as pessimistic as several of the panelists The reality is that majority of kids especially teens are savvy enough to avoid these pitfalls and plenty of parents use parental control tools or enforce family rules to help their children avoid these dangers Although users may not have full control there are often procedures to tweak the algorithms as we point out in ConnectSafely s new guide on Taking Control of Your Instagram Feed Yes bad things can happen but the vast majority of young people don t have horrific experiences online Unfortunately countless people encounter annoying scams and teens can be inundated with images of seemingly perfect lives and beautiful people which if internalized can lead to the trap of compare and despair Dwelling only on the realizable but relatively unlikely horrific outcomes would be like a pediatrician focusing on rare life-threatening diseases rather than common childhood illnesses It s not a perfect metaphor but using online services including social media is a bit like participating in sports They offer key benefits but come with inherent risks Millions of children play sports with overwhelmingly positive outcomes despite the occasional scraped knee or in rare and tragic cases serious injuries and even death A panel on bicycle safety could dwell on horrific accidents or highlight the physical and mental benefits of cycling along with common sense precautions like wearing helmets and watching out for cars Youth sports organizations work hard to make games as safe as realizable and tech companies should be held to that same standard Although I agree there is more to do including changing the way chosen of the algorithms work to keep people online longer I can say from direct experience that the safety teams at Meta TikTok Snap Discord Roblox and other companies that work with ConnectSafely are constantly seeking techniques to make their platforms safer for young users Industry weighs-in The panel did include representatives from TikTok and Roblox who as you might expect took a different tone Christine Grahn head of Citizens Approach TikTok Europe described TikTok s safety-by-design approach agreeing that countless features for minors should be off by default She pointed out that teen accounts are private by default and that teens under can t access direct messaging or group chats and their videos won t appear in the For You feed ConnectSafely s Parent s Guide to TikTok describes the safeguards for teens Roblox director of innovation Emily Yu emphasized that safety is at the heart of everything we pretty much do at Roblox noting that every new product feature is evaluated through a safety-by-design lens She highlighted the company s lately reported robust parental controls including screen time limits and content labeling to help parents better understand and manage the experiences available to their children Parents have awareness as to what an experience holds she explained and they can obviously permit or not permit their child from entering that experience Yu also addressed the role of algorithms on the platform saying Roblox focuses more on discoverability rather than limiting the content that is seen by the child based on personalization You can learn more at ConnectSafely s just now updated Parent s Guide to Roblox UNICEF s Thomas Davin compared the impact of algorithmic harm with tobacco and alcohol invoking neuroplasticity screen addiction and even the erosion of truth It s an argument I ve heard before but I d argue that it s not the full picture Yes there are teens who overuse TikTok and other platforms but there are also numerous who use them to learn new skills express creativity and engage in activism Davin also correctly pointed out that We have a hazard of children feeling less and less able to have voice and agency on how those technologies affect them impact them and maybe direct specific of what they have access to or what they can say Cultural erasure One of the takeaways from this and other panels was the concern voiced especially by participants from outside North America and Europe about how social media platforms are dominated by U S and European interests Sierra Leone s Minister of Science Tool and Innovation Salima Bah reminded attendees that a key portion of internet traffic in Sierra Leone flows through TikTok and expressed concern that algorithmic systems too often fail to reflect African identities She warned of cultural erasure when platform design decisions are made without grounding in local context Youth participation One of the panel s largest part encouraging themes was the call for meaningful youth participation in digital governance Both TikTok and Roblox highlighted their global youth councils which provide input on product and guidelines decisions Yet in a telling irony not a single child or teen was present in the room Related Articles Caltech settles class-action lawsuit accusing it of misleading students about cybersecurity bootcamp Did Gov Gavin Newsom go too far with CEQA amendment Amid office sector challenges long-delayed -million-square-foot Santa Clara enhancement makes a big pivot Disneyland had a nightmare start in but Walt s Folly speedily won over fans Restaurants bars consider turning off music as licensing fees skyrocket Larry Magid is a tech journalist and internet safety activist Contact him at larry larrymagid com